top of page

Do ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini Recommend Different Brands?

Writer: Linda Orr
Linda Orr
Nov 10
4 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

Short answer: Yes, often. In a September 2026 study of nearly 39,000 buyer questions, the brands ChatGPT and Gemini consistently recommended overlapped only 42% of the time. Even the same assistant rarely gives the same list twice. The assistants search different indexes, trust different sources and react to how the buyer phrases the question. So being recommended by one tells you very little about the others, and the work to show up in all of them looks more like content strategy and positioning than traditional SEO.


I've seen this with my own company. When buyers ask ChatGPT for a premium DTC fractional CMO or a healthcare fractional CMO, Orr Consulting is often the first name it gives. In early November, we ran 22 buyer questions through Claude with web search turned on, and it didn't name us once. Google ranked my site on page one for many of the same topics. Same company, same website, same week, three different answers.


Orr Consulting cover graphic titled "Do ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini Recommend Different Brands?" with three stats: 42% overlap in brands ChatGPT and Gemini consistently recommend, under 1 in 100 chance an assistant gives the same list twice, and 1 in 3 categories with a different first choice

1. Do ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini recommend the same brands?


Less often than most marketers assume. Searchable asked 38,966 questions about 30 times each across ChatGPT and Gemini between July and September 2026, and counted a brand as recommended only if it appeared in at least half of an engine's answers. The two engines' recommended brands overlapped just 42% of the time. A separate August 2026 study by GetIntel, which sells AI visibility software, ran about 10,000 buyer questions across 126 software categories and found ChatGPT and Gemini named a different first choice in one out of every three categories.


2. Why does the same assistant give a different answer each time?


These tools generate a fresh answer every time, and they don't keep a fixed ranked list. In a study by Rand Fishkin of SparkToro and Patrick O'Donnell of Gumshoe, hundreds of volunteers ran 12 recommendation prompts nearly 3,000 times through ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI. The odds of getting the same list of brands twice were under 1 in 100, and the same list in the same order closer to 1 in 1,000. What did hold steady was which brands showed up at all: the strongest brands appeared in roughly 60% to 90% of answers for a given question. That's the number to care about, more than your position on any single answer.


3. Why do the assistants disagree with each other?


Mostly because they look in different places. When Gemini searches the web, it uses Google. OpenAI says ChatGPT search uses third-party search providers along with its own crawler, and Bing is widely reported to be one of them. Claude's web search has been reported to run on Brave Search, which Anthropic lists as a subprocessor. If your company ranks well in Google but barely exists in Brave's index, Gemini may find you while Claude doesn't. That's likely part of what happened in our own test.


They also trust different sources. GetIntel found ChatGPT cited a product's own website in 53% of its answers, compared with 13% for Gemini. One assistant may lean on your site, another on review sites, Reddit threads or trade press.


4. Does it matter how the buyer asks?


A lot. In the SparkToro study, people asked to write their own prompt for the same need wrote almost completely different questions. GetIntel found the first choice flipped between US-phrased and UK-phrased questions in about half the categories it could measure, and one brand's share of answers ranged from 34% to 90% depending on whether the buyer described themselves as a freelancer or an enterprise. Your buyers don't all ask the same way, and each version of the question can produce a different answer.


5. How do I get my brand recommended by ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini?


The technical basics come first. AI crawlers have to be able to reach your pages, and your key text has to sit on the page rather than inside images. Beyond that, the work is mostly content strategy and positioning. Every page should answer a buyer's question plainly near the top, in words an AI tool can lift and quote. Your company should be described the same way everywhere it appears: your site, your Google Business Profile, directories, PR and social. Because each assistant trusts different sources, you need to show up in more than one place. That means reviews, trade press, industry roundups, association listings and the marketplaces AI tools cite in your category. A mention in the right trade publication can do more than ten new blog posts.


I explain why so many companies get left out in why isn't my company showing up in ChatGPT, and how to structure pages in how to optimize for AI answers. If you want a team to do this work with you on an ongoing basis, see my SEO, AEO and GEO services.


Free guide: I've put the core principles for writing pages AI tools can find and quote into a free ten-page guide, Content Optimization for LLMs: 8 Principles. Download the free LLM guide.


6. Should I pay for an AI visibility tracker?


Be careful with any tool that reports a single rank. Answers change with every run, every assistant and every phrasing, so one rank is mostly noise. What's worth tracking is how often you appear across many runs of the questions your buyers actually ask, in each assistant, and which sources the answers cite. I go through what trackers can and can't tell you in are AI visibility trackers worth it.


7. How can I check what each assistant says about my company?


Start simple. Write down the five to ten questions your buyers ask before they'd hire someone like you. Run each one several times in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity, in fresh chats, and record whether you're named, how you're described, who's named instead and which sources are cited. Patterns will show up quickly: a competitor that's everywhere, a roundup every assistant cites, or one assistant that never finds you at all.


If you'd like that done properly across your buyer questions, with the fixes ranked by impact and effort, that's what my AI Visibility Audit does. You can also start with the free LLM guide, or book a free 30-minute call and we'll look at what the assistants say about you.


Featured In Leading Media & Journals

Quoted in national media, published in peer-reviewed journals, and the author of five business books.

Forbes logo, linking to the Forbes article quoting Dr. Linda Orr on solo marketers
Entrepreneur logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s articles on Entrepreneur.com
Yahoo logo
The Daily Upside logo, linking to the Daily Upside article quoting Dr. Linda Orr on AI marketing and brand risk
business.com logo, linking to the business.com article featuring Dr. Linda Orr on offline marketing tactics
Glossy logo, linking to the Glossy Fashion Briefing article quoting Dr. Linda Orr
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article in the journal
Journal of Business Research logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article in the journal
Psychology & Marketing logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article in the journal
Journal of Business Ethics logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article in the journal
Marketing Management Journal logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article A Re-Inquiry of Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions

Why Orr Consulting

You work directly with a PhD-level strategist.

When you work with Orr Consulting, you work directly with me. I set the strategy, decide where the budget goes, and stay accountable for the results.

 

I also lead the people you already have: your internal team, agencies, developers, analysts, creatives, and specialists. You get senior direction without replacing the team you have built.

 

When you need more hands, my team does the implementation: tracking and CRM setup, web pages, email marketing, Meta and paid social, SEO and AEO, and video and image editing. I manage Google Ads myself and review everything the team delivers, so you have one point of accountability.

 

My background combines 25+ years of marketing leadership, two decades as a marketing professor, and a PhD in Marketing with depth in statistics and psychology. That work includes building Upwork's first marketing mix model across an $88M annual media portfolio.

 

Dr. Linda Orr, PhD, Founder

Dr. Linda Orr, founder of Orr Consulting

SELECTED CLIENTS AND COMPANIES

Selected Orr Consulting clients: PepsiCo, Upwork, McKesson Foster and Thrive, Midmark, FedEx Custom Critical, Arm and Hammer, TheraBreath, Mavrik Dental Systems, medmix, Elos, GFOA, Indeed, Magenta Inc, PreVu Dental, SMRTFT, Sparks, The Critical Thinking Institute, Tahoe Modern, Mayberry Law, Ollie Pediatrics, Therapevo, Mind On Photography, Artemis, Disc It
Selected Orr Consulting clients: PepsiCo, Upwork, McKesson Foster and Thrive, Midmark, FedEx Custom Critical, Arm and Hammer, TheraBreath, Mavrik Dental Systems, medmix, Elos, GFOA, Indeed, Magenta Inc, PreVu Dental, SMRTFT, Sparks, The Critical Thinking Institute, Tahoe Modern, Mayberry Law, Ollie Pediatrics, Therapevo, Mind On Photography, Artemis, Disc It (continued)

What Clients Say

Most engagements are under NDA. Here is what clients say, plus our reviews on Google.

★★★★★

“Dr. Orr's exceptional leadership and advanced knowledge in sales and marketing were invaluable. She provided practical tools our team could use immediately to perform with confidence.”

B. MacDonald

B2B Sales Enablement · Sales Training

★★★★★

“Linda was a pleasure to work with and extremely thorough. She led a market research project for our 3D dental imaging launch, and the insights directly shaped our positioning and go-to-market strategy.”

Midmark Dental

Healthcare · Market Research · Launch Strategy

★★★★★

“Working with Linda was an absolute pleasure, and the results she delivered were beyond our expectations! ... She interviewed over 20 key players in the yachting industry, ranging from yacht charter company owners to marketing managers, extracting valuable insights that we wouldn't have been able to gather on our own... The final report she presented was top-notch. It was thorough, well-structured, and packed with actionable recommendations that demonstrated her deep understanding of the industry.”

Founder, Yacht Charter Marketing Agency

Market Research · Market Entry Strategy

Prefer to Schedule Directly?

Pick a time that works for you, or start with our free guide to getting found in AI search.

Contact

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page