Who Can Run a Marketing Audit for a $10 Million Company?

Updated: 4 days ago
Short answer: For a company around $10 million in revenue, the best person to run a marketing audit is an independent senior marketer who has no stake in your current agencies or channels and can work with the data herself. Agencies tend to audit in ways that lead back to their own services, and free tool scans only look at surface metrics. A good audit reviews your channels, tracking, spend efficiency, positioning and the numbers behind your customer acquisition cost, then tells you where to put next year's money. Start well before your budget is due so you have time to act on what it finds.

Budget season is when I get the most audit requests. A CEO or CFO looks at the coming year, sees marketing as one of the biggest lines, and realizes nobody has checked in a while whether it is working. At $10 million, you are spending enough that waste matters, but you probably don't have a large internal team to sort it out.
Here is the math that makes an audit worth it. Gartner's 2025 CMO Spend Survey found marketing budgets average 7.7 percent of company revenue. For a $10 million company, that is about $770,000 a year. Finding and fixing 10 percent waste returns $77,000, every year, against an audit that starts at a few thousand dollars.
I have worked with more than 100 companies between $5 million and $500 million in revenue, and I spent about 20 years as a marketing professor before running my own practice. Here are the questions I hear most from companies at this size.
1. Who should actually run the audit?
Someone independent who has run marketing at a senior level and can do the analysis personally. That last part matters. Many consultants can talk strategy but hand the data to a junior person. Many analysts can run numbers but can't tell you whether your positioning or your offer is the real problem.
Avoid having your current agency audit itself. Even well-meaning agencies see the account through their own work. Be careful with a new agency's "free audit," too, since it is usually a sales tool designed to win the account. I wrote about this in Should You Audit Before Switching Agencies?
2. What should a marketing audit cover at $10 million?
At this size I look at five areas. First, tracking and measurement: is conversion tracking accurate, does your CRM tie back to sources, and can you trust the reports. Second, paid media efficiency across Google, Meta, LinkedIn or whatever you run. Third, organic and owned channels: SEO, email, website conversion. Fourth, positioning and messaging, because weak positioning makes every channel more expensive. Fifth, the economics: customer acquisition cost, lifetime value and payback period.
A real audit connects these. A high cost per lead on Google might be a bidding problem, or it might be a landing page problem, or it might be that your offer doesn't stand out against competitors. You only find out by looking at all of it together.
3. How is this different from a free audit or a tool scan?
Free tools like SEMrush or the Google Ads recommendations tab can flag technical issues. They can't tell you which low-volume keywords are worth keeping because they bring in your best customers, or that your conversions dropped because a competitor started undercutting you on price, or that last spring's slump was seasonality and not the agency.
The waste an audit finds is usually bigger than owners expect. In Disruptive Advertising's review of 2,167 Google Ads accounts, 42 percent had no conversion tracking at all, and every 10 percent increase in wasted spend raised cost per conversion by 44 to 72 percent. That study is from 2016, but newer work points the same way. The Association of National Advertisers estimated in 2023 that 25 percent of open-web programmatic spend, about $22 billion, was wasted, and only 36 cents of each dollar reached a consumer. Gartner found marketing leaders use only 33 percent of the capabilities in the marketing software they pay for.
I use AI and Supermetrics to speed up the data pulls, which keeps costs down. The judgment about what matters still has to come from someone who understands your market.
4. How long does an audit take?
A single-channel audit, such as Google Ads, is the quickest. A full marketing audit across channels, tracking and positioning takes longer, depending on how many channels you run and how clean the data is. I give you a timeline once I see the scope. If your budget is due in December, the best time to start is October or early November.
5. What do we need to provide?
Read access to your ad accounts, Google Analytics, Search Console and CRM. Your spend by channel for the last 12 to 24 months. Any reports your agencies have sent you. Revenue or lead data by month. A short list of the big events from the past two years, such as price changes, launches, agency switches and site redesigns. I also like to talk with whoever owns sales, because sales teams usually know which leads are good long before marketing reports show it.
6. What will we get at the end?
You get a written report and a working session with your leadership team. The report shows what is working, what is wasting money, what is broken in your tracking, and a ranked list of changes with the expected impact of each. Most important for budget season, you get a recommendation on how to split next year's budget across channels, with the reasoning behind it so your CFO can follow it. My post on how to explain marketing ROI to a CFO covers how I frame that conversation.
7. What does a marketing audit cost?
My audits are priced by scope. A Google Ads audit starts at $3,500. A multi-channel paid media audit starts at $5,500. A full Marketing Performance Audit, covering channels, tracking, positioning and economics, starts at $15,000. If you want a marketing mix model built at the same time to estimate how much each channel actually contributes, an audit plus marketing mix model starts at $20,000.
Weigh the price against the return. McKinsey estimates that 15 to 20 percent of marketing spend can be freed up through better measurement. On a $770,000 budget, that is $115,000 to $155,000 a year. If a $15,000 audit finds even a third of that, it pays for itself more than twice in the first year, and the savings repeat.
If your bigger question is where growth should come from next, my Growth Opportunity Assessment starts at $15,000, and most run $15,000 to $25,000. For a brand-focused review, brand audits start at $8,000, and most run $8,000 to $15,000. Full details are on my pricing page.
8. Why not just hire the cheapest option?
Cheaper can make sense if you are just starting out and spending very little. At $10 million in revenue, you are probably spending hundreds of thousands a year on marketing, and a weak audit that points you in the wrong direction costs more than it saves. Most of my clients tried a cheaper option first. One large professional services firm went through agency after agency, each one putting junior staff on the account. McKesson had worked with a big New York agency that didn't listen to what they actually needed. The work I do often starts with cleaning up after that.
9. What happens after the audit?
That depends on what you need. Some clients take the report and have their team or agency carry it out. Some ask me to manage their paid search, which I do on a flat fee starting at $2,750 a month plus a modest setup fee, never a percentage of spend. Some want ongoing leadership. Fractional CMO retainers start at $8,000 a month, and most engagements run $12,000 to $20,000. You don't need to decide any of that up front.
Next step
If you want a quick read on where you stand before committing to anything, take the free Marketing Measurement Scorecard or, for B2B companies, the B2B Marketing Scorecard. When you are ready to talk about timing and scope, book a free 30-minute call. You can also see how I approach marketing audits.
Related: What a Marketing Audit Should Include | How Much Does a Google Ads Audit Cost? | Is Your Agency Wasting Your Ad Budget?
Sources: Gartner CMO Spend Survey (2025); Disruptive Advertising (2016); ANA via MarTech (2023); Gartner (2023); McKinsey, Marketing return on investment.






