top of page

What Is a Marketing Efficiency Index, and Why Doesn't Your Ad Platform Calculate It?

Writer: Linda Orr
Linda Orr
5 days ago
7 min read

Every budget meeting I've sat in eventually gets to the same question. Someone from finance looks at the media plan and asks where the next dollar should go. The room goes quiet, and then each channel owner makes a case. The paid search team points to its return on ad spend. The social team points to its cost per acquisition. The agency points to a dashboard where everything is green.


When I built the first marketing mix model for a large tech marketplace, the portfolio was about $88 million a year across digital, TV, radio and out-of-home. Every platform had a number showing it was working, and together they claimed credit for more sales than the company actually made. What leadership needed was one answer that didn't come from any of those dashboards: if we move money, where does it do the most good? The answer to that question is what I call an efficiency index. Acting on it is how that company cut media spending by 25 percent while sales kept growing.


Here is the short answer. An efficiency index ranks every marketing channel by how much new revenue its next dollar would bring in, on a scale where your portfolio average is 100. Channels above 100 should get the next dollar, and channels below 100 have passed their point of diminishing returns. Ad platforms don't calculate it because each one only sees its own results, and their reports count sales that would have happened anyway.


Want to know where your next dollar should go? A paid media mix audit from $5,500 shows which channels have passed their point of diminishing returns, and marketing mix modeling gives you the full efficiency index across every channel, online and offline.


Cover graphic: What is a marketing efficiency index? Three cards show a channel at 60 (past its point of diminishing returns), the portfolio average at 100, and a channel at 140 that deserves the next dollar

1. What is a marketing efficiency index?


An efficiency index tells you how much incremental revenue the next dollar in each channel would bring in at your current spend, compared with every other channel you run. I put it on a 100 scale, with the average across your whole portfolio set to 100. A channel at 140 returns 40 percent more than your average channel on its next dollar. A channel at 60 returns 40 percent less. The plan follows directly. You move budget from channels below 100 to channels above it until the numbers start to even out.


Here's a simple illustration, with made-up numbers. Say paid search, paid social and direct mail are your three channels. Paid search brings back 90 cents of new revenue on its next dollar, paid social $1.50 and direct mail $2.10. Weighted by spend, the average is $1.20. Paid search indexes at 75, paid social at 125 and direct mail at 175. If paid search also shows the best ROAS in your reports, most teams would give it more money, and the index says to do the opposite.


2. Why isn't ROAS the same thing?


Return on ad spend is an average. It divides all the revenue a platform credits to a channel by everything you spent there. The efficiency index is about the margin: what happens to the next dollar, not the dollars you've already spent.


Those two numbers drift apart because every channel hits diminishing returns. The first dollars in paid search buy the people already looking for you. The later dollars buy broader terms, worse placements and people who were never going to buy. Your average ROAS can still look healthy long after the next dollar has stopped paying for itself, because the early, cheap wins are holding the average up. I have found the point of diminishing returns in a channel many times, and it's almost never where the team expected it. Usually the channel everyone is proudest of has passed its point, and a quieter channel with a modest average return has a lot of room left.


3. Why don't Google and Meta calculate it for you?


They can't, and they have little reason to try. Each ad platform sees only its own corner of your marketing. Google doesn't know you mailed a catalog to the same household last week. Meta doesn't know a competitor ran a sale or a heat wave cut your foot traffic. An efficiency index only means something when every channel is measured on the same basis, against the same sales, with those outside forces accounted for. No platform has that view, and none of them would be the neutral party in deciding whose budget gets cut.


The bigger problem is that platform reports count conversions that would have happened anyway. When economists at eBay switched off their branded search ads in a controlled test, about 99.5 percent of the traffic still arrived through the free listings, and the estimated return on their non-brand search spend was negative 63 percent. A 2023 study by Brett Gordon, Robert Moakler and Florian Zettelmeyer compared 663 randomized Facebook experiments with the measurement methods advertisers normally use. For lower-funnel ads, the randomized tests found a median lift of 5 percent. The standard methods put it somewhere between 24 and 64 percent. When the starting numbers are inflated that much, ranking channels by them sends money to the wrong place.


4. What happens if you never calculate it?


The most common mistake is pouring money into a saturated channel because its average return looks strong, while starving the channels that are still on the steep part of their curve. Nielsen's 2022 ROI report, built on marketing mix models and attribution studies, found that about half of all media plans were underinvested and that the median underinvested plan was short by 50 percent. Nielsen estimated that fixing the budget level could improve return on investment by about 50 percent. Underinvestment and overinvestment usually exist in the same plan at the same time, in different channels. You can't see either one without a measure of the next dollar.


The second risk is cutting the wrong things when budgets tighten. Gartner's 2025 CMO Spend Survey found marketing budgets flat at 7.7 percent of company revenue, and its June 2026 survey found spending on loyalty and retention had fallen 29 percent since 2024. When the pressure is on, teams cut what's hardest to defend with a platform dashboard: brand, upper funnel, offline and retention. Those are often the channels with the most room left on their curves.


The third risk is slower but more expensive. Without an efficiency index, every budget conversation becomes a negotiation between channel owners, each holding a number from a system that grades its own work. Leadership ends up funding whoever argues best. I've watched companies do this for years and then wonder why spending keeps rising while growth stays flat.


5. How do you actually calculate an efficiency index?


It comes out of a properly built marketing mix model. I start with the strategy and the hypotheses, then build the model on two to three years of weekly sales and spend data. Before any modeling, I decide how to account for seasonality, weather, competitors, pricing, promotions and brand activity, because a model that ignores them hands their effect to whichever channel happened to be running at the time.


The model estimates two things for each channel. Carryover covers how long an ad keeps working after it runs. Saturation covers where the response curve flattens. From those curves I calculate the marginal return at your current spend level, then divide each channel's marginal return by the spend-weighted average across all channels and multiply by 100. The result is a single comparable number for every channel, including streaming, billboards, direct mail and catalogs, which most platform reporting can't measure at all.


The model itself is only half the work. Someone with real budget experience has to read the curves, check them against what the business knows, and turn them into a plan the CFO can hold you to.


6. How should you use it in budget planning?


Treat the index as a direction, not a formula to run blindly. I move money in steps, from the lowest-indexed channels to the highest, and then recalculate, because the index changes as spend moves. A channel at 175 won't stay there if you double its budget. That's diminishing returns working in the other direction.


I also look at the index next to the business plan. A channel below 100 might still be the right place for money if it supports a launch, a new market or a brand position you're building on purpose. The index tells you what each dollar costs you, and leadership decides what's worth paying for.


7. How often should you recalculate it?


More often than most teams expect. With my clients, budget questions come up almost constantly, so I keep the index current and update it whenever the mix changes meaningfully: a new channel, a big shift in spend, a price change or a new competitor. At a minimum, review it every quarter alongside the budget and rebuild the underlying model at least once a year. That keeps the conversation about where the next dollar goes and away from which team gets credit.


8. Does a smaller company need one?


If you spend in only one or two channels, a full model may be more than you need, and a paid media mix audit is a better first step. Once you're running four or more channels and spending enough that a 10 percent reallocation is real money, the efficiency index is the most useful single number I know of for keeping that budget honest.


Ready to find out where your next dollar should go? Book a strategy call and we'll talk through whether a paid media mix audit or a full marketing mix model fits your budget. For more on the business case, read how to build a business case for marketing mix modeling and what marketing mix modeling costs.


Sources: Blake, Nosko and Tadelis, "Consumer Heterogeneity and Paid Search Effectiveness: A Large-Scale Field Experiment," Econometrica, 2015; Gordon, Moakler and Zettelmeyer, "Close Enough? A Large-Scale Exploration of Non-Experimental Approaches to Advertising Measurement," Marketing Science, 2023; Nielsen ROI Report, 2022; Gartner 2025 CMO Spend Survey; Gartner marketing survey, June 2026.



Featured In Leading Media & Journals

Quoted in national media, published in peer-reviewed journals, and the author of five business books.

Forbes logo, linking to the Forbes article quoting Dr. Linda Orr on solo marketers
Entrepreneur logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s articles on Entrepreneur.com
Yahoo logo
The Daily Upside logo, linking to the Daily Upside article quoting Dr. Linda Orr on AI marketing and brand risk
business.com logo, linking to the business.com article featuring Dr. Linda Orr on offline marketing tactics
Glossy logo, linking to the Glossy Fashion Briefing article quoting Dr. Linda Orr
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article in the journal
Journal of Business Research logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article in the journal
Psychology & Marketing logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article in the journal
Journal of Business Ethics logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article in the journal
Marketing Management Journal logo, linking to Dr. Linda Orr’s article A Re-Inquiry of Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions

Why Orr Consulting

You work directly with a PhD-level strategist.

When you work with Orr Consulting, you work directly with me. I set the strategy, decide where the budget goes, and stay accountable for the results.

 

I also lead the people you already have: your internal team, agencies, developers, analysts, creatives, and specialists. You get senior direction without replacing the team you have built.

 

When you need more hands, my team does the implementation: tracking and CRM setup, web pages, email marketing, Meta and paid social, SEO and AEO, and video and image editing. I manage Google Ads myself and review everything the team delivers, so you have one point of accountability.

 

My background combines 25+ years of marketing leadership, two decades as a marketing professor, and a PhD in Marketing with depth in statistics and psychology. That work includes building Upwork's first marketing mix model across an $88M annual media portfolio.

 

Dr. Linda Orr, PhD, Founder

Dr. Linda Orr, founder of Orr Consulting

SELECTED CLIENTS AND COMPANIES

Selected Orr Consulting clients: PepsiCo, Upwork, McKesson Foster and Thrive, Midmark, FedEx Custom Critical, Arm and Hammer, TheraBreath, Mavrik Dental Systems, medmix, Elos, GFOA, Indeed, Magenta Inc, PreVu Dental, SMRTFT, Sparks, The Critical Thinking Institute, Tahoe Modern, Mayberry Law, Ollie Pediatrics, Therapevo, Mind On Photography, Artemis, Disc It
Selected Orr Consulting clients: PepsiCo, Upwork, McKesson Foster and Thrive, Midmark, FedEx Custom Critical, Arm and Hammer, TheraBreath, Mavrik Dental Systems, medmix, Elos, GFOA, Indeed, Magenta Inc, PreVu Dental, SMRTFT, Sparks, The Critical Thinking Institute, Tahoe Modern, Mayberry Law, Ollie Pediatrics, Therapevo, Mind On Photography, Artemis, Disc It (continued)

What Clients Say

Most engagements are under NDA. Here is what clients say, plus our reviews on Google.

★★★★★

“Dr. Orr's exceptional leadership and advanced knowledge in sales and marketing were invaluable. She provided practical tools our team could use immediately to perform with confidence.”

B. MacDonald

B2B Sales Enablement · Sales Training

★★★★★

“Linda was a pleasure to work with and extremely thorough. She led a market research project for our 3D dental imaging launch, and the insights directly shaped our positioning and go-to-market strategy.”

Midmark Dental

Healthcare · Market Research · Launch Strategy

★★★★★

“Working with Linda was an absolute pleasure, and the results she delivered were beyond our expectations! ... She interviewed over 20 key players in the yachting industry, ranging from yacht charter company owners to marketing managers, extracting valuable insights that we wouldn't have been able to gather on our own... The final report she presented was top-notch. It was thorough, well-structured, and packed with actionable recommendations that demonstrated her deep understanding of the industry.”

Founder, Yacht Charter Marketing Agency

Market Research · Market Entry Strategy

Prefer to Schedule Directly?

Pick a time that works for you, or start with our free guide to getting found in AI search.

Contact

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page