How to Be a Good Client: What Every Freelancer and Consultant Is Dying to Tell You

Updated: 5 days ago

Many times, projects fail because of the client's communication and behavior, even when the consultant is highly skilled. You are spending way too much money to have a project fail because of things that are 100% in your control. Whether you're hiring a marketing consultant, a lawyer, an accountant, or a designer, how you show up as a client shapes what you get back.
Here is the short answer. A good client hires for a real, achievable scope instead of a "unicorn," hands over the information and access the consultant needs, names one point of contact, responds on time, respects the consultant's schedule and expertise, listens to feedback that stings, pays on time at a fair rate, and says thank you in ways that help the consultant's business. Do those things and you give the project a real chance to succeed.
1. Why do so many consulting projects fail before they start?
Projects frequently fail at the moment the job description or request for proposal is written. In my years of consulting, I have learned that the number one red flag for project failure is a client seeking a unicorn, guru, rockstar, magician, or someone who can "work wonders." Unicorns are imaginary. They don't exist.
You may think a catchy phrase will attract more proposals. But if you genuinely need someone who doesn't exist, step back and ask why the project is so hard. Are you trying to dramatically increase brand awareness on a shoestring budget? Is the product or service itself not very good? Do you want one person with an enormous variety of skills when you really need a team? A clear, honest scope attracts the right people and filters out the ones who will promise anything.
2. What does it mean if you've been through several freelancers already?
I also see a red flag when clients trash-talk the other freelancers they've used. It's common to hear it during project interviews: "We hired someone to do SEO and rankings didn't improve. Then we hired an ad agency and weren't happy with the results. Then we tried a digital expert and sales still didn't improve."
I understand. Plenty of consultants and agencies don't do good work. But if you've had the same problem with several of them, it may be time to look inward. Take a hard look at the project and ask why it seems to need something unrealistic. Sometimes the issue is the offer, the budget, the data, or the lack of anyone internally who owns the strategy. My post on when to fire your marketing agency walks through how to separate an agency problem from a problem upstream of the agency.
In my book, When to Hire or Not Hire a Consultant: Getting Your Money's Worth from Consulting Relationships, I include a flowchart that explains when a consultant can help and when they can't. It's worth working through before you write the next job post.
3. What should you give a consultant at the start?
Good communication matters in any working relationship, and it's essential with a professional who needs to understand your needs, goals, and expectations. Give them your goals, your expectations, and your timeline up front. Share the data, logins, past reports, and context they ask for, in an organized way and on time. Consultants can't read your mind, and they can't work with information they don't have.
I begin projects with a thorough onboarding form, but there's no way I can ask every relevant question at the start of a project. The more you volunteer, the better the outcome. It's fine to hire a consultant to set up your marketing technology because you don't have clean data yet. Just be clear about that, and be clear about what you expect at the end.
4. Why does a single point of contact matter so much?
Reply in a timely way, and give the consultant one point of contact. One of my big projects with a large client was difficult because I never had a single point of contact. The VP hired me, and I spoke to her maybe three more times. The project was handed to an employee who had just moved to a different division and didn't have time to manage it. Then, when I talked with the Senior VP, he had no idea what I had been hired to do and kept giving me different jobs outside the original scope.
One consistent contact would have fixed all of that. That person keeps the scope steady, gets answers from the right people inside the company, and makes decisions or knows who can. If several leaders care about the project, that's fine, but route their input through one owner so the consultant isn't getting conflicting direction.
5. How do you respect a consultant's time without micromanaging?
Professionals are busy, and their time is what they sell. Show up to meetings on time and prepared, send materials in advance, and answer emails and messages promptly. Trust their expertise and let them do the work you hired them for without second-guessing every decision.
It also means understanding that people take time off, and most people don't work outside business hours. Agree on boundaries early: how often you'll meet, how you'll check in, and which channel you'll use for what. For fractional executives, this includes their calendar. I wrote about what happens when clients treat white space on a shared calendar as open time in what I hate about being a fractional CMO. The short version is to ask before you book.
6. How should you handle feedback you don't want to hear?
Working with a consultant is a collaboration. Be open to their ideas and suggestions, even when they differ from your original vision. A consultant sees your business from the outside, without the built-in assumptions your own team has. Sometimes it hurts to hear that the way you've been doing something isn't working. When it does, remember why you hired them in the first place.
Feedback runs both ways. Give your own feedback respectfully and specifically, and be willing to adjust the plan when the evidence says you should. The best engagements have a rhythm where the consultant brings recommendations, you push back where you know something they don't, and together you land on a better answer than either side would have reached alone.
7. What does paying fairly actually mean?
Like any business, consultants and freelancers rely on timely, fair payment to keep running. Honor the payment terms you agreed to and send any paperwork they need promptly. If you can't pay on time, say so early and honestly and work out a solution together. And don't expect work to begin, or someone to hold space on their calendar, until the contract is signed and the first payment is made.
Also, don't expect expert-level help at entry-level rates. The "you get what you pay for" rule generally holds in consulting. The big consulting firms are known to charge rates out of proportion to the skill of the people doing the work. Outside of those, someone's rate is usually a good signal of the quality you'll get. If you're hiring a senior marketing leader, my guide to what to look for when hiring a fractional CMO covers how to judge fit beyond the hourly number.
8. How do you show appreciation in a way that actually helps?
Finally, show appreciation for the people who do good work for you. Acknowledge their effort and their contribution to your results. That can be a thank-you note or email, a referral, or simply saying it out loud. Online reviews are very helpful and always appreciated. For an independent consultant, a specific, public review is one of the most valuable things a client can give.

9. What does a good client checklist look like?
If you want a quick self-check before your next engagement starts, run through this list:
The scope is realistic for the budget and timeline, with no "unicorn" language.
You've looked honestly at why past freelancers or agencies didn't work out.
Goals, expectations, data, and logins are ready before kickoff.
One named person owns the project on your side and can make decisions.
Meeting cadence, response times, and working hours are agreed up front.
You're prepared to hear that something you've been doing isn't working.
The contract is signed and the first payment is scheduled before work begins.
You've budgeted for the level of expertise the project actually needs.
You'll leave a review or make a referral if the work is good.
Being a good client is how you build strong, productive relationships with the professionals you hire. Don't expect success if you don't set the project up for success. If you're thinking about bringing in senior marketing leadership and want to set it up right from day one, read my guide on how to hire a fractional CMO, or book a free 30-minute introductory call here.
Dr. Linda Orr, PhD, is the founder of Orr Consulting, a fractional CMO and marketing analytics practice serving brands from $5M to $500M in revenue. She built Upwork's first enterprise marketing mix model, covering an $88M annual media portfolio, and spent about 20 years as a marketing professor before moving fully into consulting.






